Tithely vs Pushpay Pricing (2026)
Compare / Tithely vs Pushpay
Shortlist
Team size
25 seats

Tithely vs Pushpay

Church Management pricing comparison · 2026

Tithely has a free plan, then $19–$119/mo, while Pushpay is quote-based. These products use different pricing models ( vs Custom enterprise pricing), so a direct price comparison isn't meaningful — costs depend on usage volume and mix.

Visit
See pricing on each vendor's site
Above-the-fold path — each link opens the vendor's pricing page in a new tab.
Visit Tithely pricing
Free plan limits → Discount programs →
Visit Pushpay pricing
Discount programs →
Compare
2 products · Church Management
Side-by-side · live
Tithely
Tithely pricing starts with Free Online Giving at $0/mo.
verified 6d ago
$864 $3.0K
View pricing →
Pushpay
Pushpay offers three tiers—Core, Advanced, and Complete—all with custom pricing quoted bas
verified 4mo ago
$864 $3.0K
View pricing →
Estimated license cost
at 25 seats
List price × seats. Click a tier below to lock it.
Church Management
$864/yr
year 1 license · flat plan price
Custom pricing
Custom
all tiers are quote-only
What buyers actually pay
median, annual
Vendr deal-flow data. The real benchmark, not list price.
No Vendr data
—
Not in Vendr's deal flow
Median annual
$3.0K/yr
Vendr · n=1 · limited data
REF · 01

Sources & confidence

Every dollar amount and contract clause below traces back to a sourced fact. We don't manufacture composite scores.

Where this data comes from
Vendr · TrustRadius · Reddit · BBB · official docs
Sources 12 sourced facts
9 hidden-cost · 1 contract · 2 review platforms
Last verified 6d ago
Confidence Medium confidence
Sources 8 sourced facts
4 hidden-cost · 2 contract · Vendr median · 1 review platform
Last verified 3mo ago
Confidence Limited confidence
REF · 02

Plans at a glance

Every tier per product. Lock one to drive the cost row above and reveal a tier-specific outbound CTA.

Tier ladder
Click a tier to lock the cost row to it. Locking surfaces a tier-specific Visit CTA.
REF · 03

Hidden costs

Each cost is severity-ranked, with the dollar range quoted from its source (Vendr, Reddit, TrustRadius, BBB, official docs) — never our estimate.

Beyond the sticker
Severity-ranked, sourced
5 documented
  • Text Giving Subscription
    $19 per month
    1 source
  • Text-to-give Setup Fee
    $25
    1 source
  • Custom Church App Subscription
    $89 per month
    1 source
  • Tithely Messaging Overage
    1.9¢ each
    1 source
  • Premium Support
    $29 per month
    1 source
3 documented
  • Credit Card Transaction Fees
    2.9%
    1 source
  • Annual Contract Lock-In During Migration
    Remaining monthly platform fees through the end of the contract term; Pushpay's Core, Advanced and Complete plans are custom-quoted, so the amount depends on the quote.
    1 source
  • Platform Fees Higher Than Competitors
    10-20% of donation revenue
    2 sources
REF · 04

Contract terms

The fine print, surfaced. Green = buyer-friendly. Each clause backed by a quoted source.

Tithely
Pushpay
Auto-renewal
Yes
Yes
Cancellation
before next scheduled renewal date
Must complete full annual contract term
Commitment
none
1 year
Price escalation
—
—
Can downgrade
—
No
Based on 3 verified sources (Vendr · TrustRadius · BBB)
REF · 05

What users say

Aggregated, with sample sizes. We use whichever review platform has data.

User reviews
TrustRadius · Trustpilot · G2
Trustpilot
4.7out of 5 (1,100)
G2
4.7out of 5 (2,026)
Best for
Churches getting started with digital giving
Watch out
Delayed Payment Processing
TrustRadius
8out of 5 (16)
Best for
Small churches starting digital giving
Watch out
Excessively high fees compared to alternative platforms
Decide
Get a quote from each vendor
Each link opens the vendor's pricing page in a new tab.
Visit Tithely pricing
Free plan limits → Discount programs →
Visit Pushpay pricing
Discount programs →
License cost is computed from publicly listed plans (real math, list price × seats). Median annual cost is from Vendr's deal flow when available — see source badges. Hidden costs and contract terms each cite their own sources. We do not invent composite scores.
Church Management

Tithely

Free plan; paid $19–$119
/mo
5 plans · Free tier
Full pricing breakdown →
VS
Church Management

Pushpay

Custom pricing
3 plans
Full pricing breakdown →
⚖

Different Pricing Models

Direct price comparison isn't meaningful here — Tithely uses pricing while Pushpay uses Custom enterprise pricing pricing. Your actual cost will depend on usage volume, team size, or both. Here's each product in its native unit.

Tithely

Free plan; paid $19–$119/mo
See full Tithely pricing →
vs
Custom enterprise pricing

Pushpay

Custom pricing
See full Pushpay pricing →

Tithely and Pushpay both operate in the church management category. This page compares their list pricing.

Plan-by-Plan Pricing

Plan Tithely Pushpay
Free Giving Free /month Custom
Website $19 /month Custom
Church Management $72 /month Custom
Mobile Church App $89 /month —
All-Access $119 /month —

Hidden Costs

Beyond the sticker price — what catches buyers off guard.

Tithely 9 hidden costs

medium
Text Giving Subscription $19 per month
low
Text-to-give Setup Fee $25
medium
Custom Church App Subscription $89 per month
medium
Tithely Messaging Overage 1.9¢ each
medium
Premium Support $29 per month
See all Tithely hidden costs →

Pushpay 3 hidden costs

medium
Credit Card Transaction Fees 2.9%
critical
Annual Contract Lock-In During Migration Remaining monthly platform fees through the end of the contract term; Pushpay's Core, Advanced and Complete plans are custom-quoted, so the amount depends on the quote.
high
Platform Fees Higher Than Competitors 10-20% of donation revenue
See all Pushpay hidden costs →

Contract Terms

Term Tithely Pushpay
Auto-renewal Yes Yes
Cancellation before next scheduled renewal date Must complete full annual contract term
Minimum commitment none 1 year
Can downgrade — No

Continue researching

Tithely

Pushpay

Related Comparisons