Printify vs Sellfy 2026: Pricing Compared

Printify vs Sellfy

E-commerce pricing comparison · 2026

Printify pricing ranges from $39–$39/month, while Sellfy ranges from $22–$159/month. Printify is typically 34% more affordable, though your actual cost depends on tier and team size.

E-commerce

Printify

$39–$39
/month
3 plans · Free tier
Full pricing breakdown →
VS
E-commerce

Sellfy

$22–$159
/month
3 plans
Full pricing breakdown →

Printify and Sellfy serve different segments of the creator economy. Printify is a print-on-demand marketplace connecting sellers with 80+ print providers for custom physical products like t-shirts and mugs, while Sellfy is an all-in-one storefront platform built for selling digital products, subscriptions, and print-on-demand items from a single dashboard.

Printify offers a genuinely free plan with no monthly cost (you pay only per-order production costs), plus a Premium plan at $39/month that unlocks up to 20% product discounts. Sellfy has no free tier for active selling and starts at $29/month (Starter) with a $10K annual revenue cap, scaling to $159/month (Premium) for up to $200K in annual sales. The key tradeoff: Printify is cheaper to start but requires a separate storefront (Shopify, Etsy), while Sellfy includes its own store but caps your revenue per plan.

Plan-by-Plan Pricing

Plan Printify Sellfy
Free Free /month $29 /month
Premium $39 /month $79 /month
Enterprise Custom $159 /month

Cost at Scale

Total cost of ownership — licenses, implementation, and hidden costs included.

Printify

6 scenarios
$340/month ($0 subscription + $240 product costs + $100 shipping)
Hobby Seller (Free Plan, ~20 sales/month)
$1,285/month ($25 subscription + $800 product costs + $460 shipping)
Growing Store (Premium Plan, ~100 sales/month)
$5,525/month ($25 subscription + $3,500 product costs + $2,000 shipping)
Established Brand (Premium Plan, ~500 sales/month)
See all 6 scenarios →

Sellfy

6 scenarios
$264/year
Hobbyist Creator
+ $175 processing fees = $439/year
$708/year
Growing Creator
+ $1,080 processing fees = $1,788/year
$1,428/year
Full-Time Creator
+ $5,250 processing fees = $6,678/year
See all 6 scenarios →

What Users Say

Printify

Trustpilot
4.6/5 (25)
Top complaints
  • Product pricing too high compared to competitors and direct manufacturers
  • Customer service quality dropped significantly and slow to respond
  • Inconsistent quality between different print providers

Sellfy

G2
4/5 (56)
Trustpilot
4.2/5 (68)
Top complaints
  • Expensive premium plans required after 14-day trial
  • Restricted website customization options
  • Limited to only PayPal and Stripe payment processors

Hidden Costs

Beyond the sticker price — what catches buyers off guard.

Printify 13 hidden costs

high
Shipping Costs Vary Dramatically by Provider and Destination $3-$15+ per item shipped
high
Print Quality Inconsistency Across Providers Causes Returns and Lost Sales 5-15% return rate on affected orders
medium
Premium Plan Is Non-Refundable and Auto-Renews $299/year if forgotten
medium
Unfulfilled Orders and Lost Production Costs Full production cost per failed order
high
Middleman Markup Over Direct Manufacturing 30-60% of product costs
See all Printify hidden costs →

Sellfy 8 hidden costs

high
Revenue Caps Force Plan Upgrades $50-$80/month on forced upgrade
medium
Payment Processing Fees $0.30 + 2.9% per transaction
medium
Limited Customization Requires Developer $500-$2,000 for custom design work
high
Annual Sales Revenue Caps 100-450% plan cost increase when forced to upgrade
low
Platform Branding on Storefront $50/month to remove (Business plan upgrade cost)
See all Sellfy hidden costs →

Contract Terms

Term Printify Sellfy
Auto-renewal
Cancellation
Minimum commitment
Price escalation Print providers periodically update pricing approximately every 6 months, with price changes rolled out without always providing advance notice to users
Can downgrade No

Our Verdict

Choose Printify if you already have a storefront on Shopify, Etsy, or another marketplace and want the widest selection of print-on-demand products with no monthly subscription cost. The Free plan works well for testing products, and Premium at $39/month ($24.99/month annually) is worthwhile once you hit 15+ sales per month.

Choose Sellfy if you sell digital products (ebooks, courses, music) alongside physical merchandise and want a simple all-in-one store without managing separate platforms. The Starter plan at $29/month includes digital product delivery, subscriptions, and basic print-on-demand. Just watch the $10K annual revenue cap, which forces an upgrade to the $79/month Business plan as you grow.

Frequently Asked Questions

01 Is Printify cheaper than Sellfy?

Printify is cheaper to start since it has a free plan with no monthly subscription. You only pay per-order production costs ($5-15 per item) plus shipping ($3-8 domestic). Sellfy requires at least $29/month (Starter) to sell anything. However, Printify requires a separate storefront like Shopify ($39/month), which can make total costs comparable.

02 Can I sell digital products on Printify?

No, Printify only supports print-on-demand physical products. For digital products like ebooks, courses, or music downloads, Sellfy is the better choice with built-in digital delivery on all plans starting at $29/month (Starter).

03 Does Sellfy have revenue limits?

Yes, Sellfy enforces strict annual sales caps: $10K on Starter ($29/month), $50K on Business ($79/month), and $200K on Premium ($159/month). Exceeding your cap may trigger a 2% overage fee or force an upgrade. Printify has no revenue limits on any plan.

04 Which is better for print-on-demand, Printify or Sellfy?

Printify is significantly better for print-on-demand. It offers 80+ print providers, 900+ product types, and up to 20% product discounts on the Premium plan ($39/month). Sellfy includes basic POD functionality but with a much smaller product catalog and fewer customization options.

05 Do I need Shopify to use Printify?

No, but you need some storefront. Printify integrates with Shopify, Etsy, eBay, WooCommerce, and other marketplaces. It does not include its own store. Sellfy includes a built-in storefront with all plans, making it simpler if you do not want to manage a separate platform.